Virtualization Technology News and Information
Stop Worrying How Virtualization Relates to Cloud Computing in 2010


What do Virtualization and Cloud executives think about 2010?  Find out in this series exclusive.

Contributed Article By Barry Lynn, Chairman and CEO of 3Tera, Inc.

The Future of Virtualization or How I Stopped Worrying How it Relates to Cloud Computing in 2010

I don't know why, but I am still surprised when I hear the following question: "What's the difference between virtualization and Cloud?" To me, it's like asking the question, "What's the difference between a hammer and carpentry?"  The latter is a comprehensive craft. The former is one of many tools used by the craftsmen who practice it.

Simple - right?  So why does that question occur at all?

It occurs, in my opinion, for two reasons - one right and one not so right.

The first reason is that all of the server virtualization vendors of any significance are also introducing Cloud offerings to the market, so people are naturally associating the two (and rightfully so, just like one would associate hammers to carpentry). The difference though, is no one thinks hammers and carpentry is the same thing.

Onto the not so right reason - There are Cloud computing laggards out there who would like us to think that virtualization and Cloud are similar because they have embraced virtualization technology and do not want to appear out of step. As a result, there is a ton of noise in the market that is very hard to sort through.

So, how do I suggest one sorts through this noise?

When faced with a potential Cloud solution, ask a few questions about it.

Does it help me provision and deploy virtual machines on demand? If the answer is no, I'd ask why are you even looking at it?  But if the answer is yes, just deploying VMs on-demand does not make a Cloud.

Does it enable the encapsulation and on-demand deployment of multiple VMs as a single entity? If rather than managing VMs, you want to manage frequently used "appliances" that are comprised of multiple VMs (e.g. a specific app server, a specific messaging system and a specific database server), can you do it?  If the answer is yes, you are on your way to a real Cloud solution.

Does it enable the encapsulation and on-demand deployment of whole software stacks (e.g. LAMP, Ruby on Rails, .NET, etc.)? If the answer is yes, you are certainly in the Cloud.

But, do you want more? Does it enable encapsulation and on-demand deployment of entire multi-tiered apps? If yes, you have a very powerful Cloud solution.

More? Does it enable the encapsulation of the apps along with everything they need to run - network, storage, infrastructure, configurations, policies, documentation, etc., etc., etc.? If yes, then you have the most complete Cloud solution of all.

So, you might sense a theme here - encapsulation. Yes, encapsulation is key, but it is only half of the story. Encapsulation itself results in many benefits, especially operational cost savings and decreased time to market. But encapsulation alone does not make a Cloud. It does not create portability. It does not create the ability, by itself, to deploy anywhere, any time.

What's the second half of the story? Abstraction. Not only do the most comprehensive Cloud solutions have to provide unlimited granularity of encapsulation, but they must completely abstract what is encapsulated from the physical resources (machines) they run on, so that they can run anytime, anywhere there are available idle resources.

In short, you do not measure a Cloud solution by how it does virtualization. You measure it by the granularity of its encapsulation capabilities and its ability to abstract VMs, stacks, apps/services and entire datacenters from the physical resources on which they run.

So, what is the future of virtualization and where is it going in 2010?

Virtualization is going the way of the hammer. It will be a necessary commodity for the Cloud, just like the hammer is a necessary commodity for the carpenter.

Now, before all the virtualization vendors get their shorts in a knot and start screaming at me that I am implying that all virtualization is the same, I am not. I acknowledge that some have features others do not, some outperform others, etc. But, can you tell who the best carpenter is by only knowing what brand of hammer he uses?

About the Author

Barry Lynn, Chairman and CEO of 3Tera, Inc., has a storied career in datacenter innovation and a deep understanding of enterprise customers and applications. He has over 37 years of executive experience in the IT and financial services sectors in Fortune 100 companies and as an entrepreneur. Early in his career, Barry was with Wells Fargo at numerous positions, most recently he was EVP and head of Investment Operations before becoming chief information officer (CIO) of Wells Fargo and Company and president of Wells Fargo Technology Services. In 1995, while at Wells Fargo, he built the world's first Internet online banking system. Barry was also president of Wells Fargo Securities, Inc. Prior to 3Tera, Barry founded Be eXceL management, Inc., a management consulting firm, which incubated early stage technology companies. Additionally, he served as Chairman and CEO of PRIVACI, a provider of anonymous purchasing and personalized services for Internet consumers. He was Director of Merant PLC, currently on the Boards of Directors of Alacritech and Layer 7 Technologies.

Published Friday, January 08, 2010 3:00 AM by David Marshall
Twitter Trackbacks for Stop Worrying How Virtualization Relates to Cloud Computing in 2010 : - Virtualization Technology [] on - (Author's Link) - January 8, 2010 3:17 AM
uberVU - social comments - (Author's Link) - January 8, 2010 3:25 AM

This post was mentioned on Twitter by virtnews: Stop Worrying How Virtualization Relates to Cloud Computing in 2010 Full

Stop Worrying How Virtualization Relates to Cloud Computing in … Information - (Author's Link) - January 8, 2010 6:57 AM
Stop Worrying How Virtualization Relates to Cloud Computing in … | Web Hosting Geeks - Shared Web Hosting, VPS, Dedicated Servers, Virtualization and Cloud Computing - (Author's Link) - January 8, 2010 10:56 AM
Stop Worrying How Virtualization Relates to Cloud Computing in … | VirtualizationDir - Top Virtualization Providers, News and Resources - (Author's Link) - January 8, 2010 11:23 AM » Open Source Xen Hypervisor & Xen Cloud Platform (XCP) adopted by private IaaS providers – CloudCentral - (Author's Link) - January 9, 2010 5:40 AM
BjarneRasmussenCA - (Author's Link) - January 21, 2010 5:33 AM

Virtualisation is an enabler, or tool, of Cloud, in the same way a hammer is an enabler of carpentry.  Barry is right in the many other aspects he mentions that comprise a Cloud solution.  Other elements include the ability to leverage physical systems in addition to virtualised environments as part of a Cloud.  A more mature Cloud Solution also needs interfaces or capability to detect and dynamically add server capacity.  It should also have a sophisticated interface to allow users to request resource as required, and be accessible through a Service Catalog documenting all of the Services offered by IT.  Cloud solutions must also have the ability to be measured against Service Levels, and although perhaps a future requirement for some companies, offer an ability to charge users by consumption.  See why CA acquired Oblicore at

To post a comment, you must be a registered user. Registration is free and easy! Sign up now!
<January 2010>