Opens in a new tab
vmblog logo 2024 wht (updated)

Four Mistakes Companies Make When Choosing SaaS tools – and How to Avoid Them

Share: 

David Marshall | Published: May 23, 2022

By Christina Kearney, Chief Marketing Officer, SoftwareReviews

Choosing the right SaaS (Software as a Service) suite is no small feat. Leaders need to be well-informed on the needs of the organization, the capabilities of the provider, and the company budget to find a provider that meets their expectations. While there are common best practices that can be used to guide decision-making, even with the best guidance, mistakes can be made. Here are four of the most common mistakes enterprises make when choosing SaaS tools – and how to avoid them.

1.      An inadequate understanding of critical requirements. When choosing a technology solutions provider, leaders must take the time to build out a formal selection process. Formalizing the software selection process through documentation and tiered steps makes it easier to gain a deep understanding of critical business needs. The needs of each business unit, how different stakeholders interact with the technology, customer expectations, and how a new tool could affect those relationships are just a few of the critical questions that need to guide the selection process.

To formalize the software selection process, leaders should use a templated framework and document that can be shared throughout the organization and outlines the application selection process from start to finish. It should include distinct phases with key activities, outputs, and decision criteria defined for each step in the process. Info-Tech Research Group’s Rapid Application Selection Framework is an example of a framework that is best geared towards commodity and mid-tier enterprise applications. It includes five phases – 1) Awareness, 2) Education and Discovery, 3) Evaluation, 4) Selection, and 5) Negotiation and Configuration – that add rigor to the selection effort and provide an easy-to-follow methodology. Critical stages include understanding critical needs and impact, validating the business case, understanding current market capabilities, and conducting investigative research from multiple sources.

This documented approach gives the whole organization a chance to align on best practices across the board and ensure that each stakeholder is adequately informed of the criteria guiding the selection process (and has the opportunity to provide input as well – but more on that later).

Organizations that fail to do this important discovery work often find themselves saddled with solutions that, at best, only partially address their needs or, at worst, need to be replaced. This can result in a waste of resources, as well as a decrease in business efficiency and productivity.

2.      Having a short-term view. SaaS selection is a long-term decision, one that affects every aspect of a business. Companies must keep this in mind when choosing a software solutions provider and not prioritize cost over long-term value. The expectation is that these solutions should facilitate and align with growth plans and maintain their value as this growth occurs.

Every time there is an organizational change, these tools should be reevaluated to ensure that they continue to meet critical business needs now and in the future. Companies should assess the long-term viability of software in areas such as scalability, integration, customization, governance and risk management, maintenance, and provider innovation in the context of the unique technology and business environment. When reevaluating existing tools, there are a few questions organizations should consider, including: Are there gaps in the current technology portfolio based on feedback from business stakeholders? What new customer experience and product capabilities can drive future growth for the business? Where can the organization deploy technology to improve key business metrics? How can the organization improve productivity?

3.      Falling for stakeholder bias. Between salespersons, investors, partners, and competitors, there are many parties that can influence software purchasing decisions. While it is necessary to source feedback and ideas from these groups, IT and business leaders should be cognizant of their susceptibility to stakeholder bias – and take steps to mitigate its effects. To do this, prioritize data-driven insights and use independent reviews from trusted sources as secondary research when choosing a SaaS provider.

Review websites often have rigorous methodologies for gathering, evaluating, and publishing reviews, making them an excellent source not only for learning the pros and cons of a specific tool but understanding what it means to be a customer of that brand. Beyond the technology’s capabilities and features, understanding what it means to be a customer of a specific provider is often an underutilized aspect of the software selection process. Consider a review platform that offers an assessment of the provider relationship and emotional measures related to product impact, customer relationship, conflict resolution, negotiation and contract experience, and service experience.

Using more than one review platform for input into your decision-making process is important as the questions asked of buyers and the level of detail will vary significantly. A best practice for leaders to ensure the validity and quality of a review platform is to trial the review process themselves by submitting a review for a product they have used. Understanding first-hand the depth of the survey, the aspects that are covered, and survey length will help leaders determine which platforms will give them the most well-rounded information to improve their selection decisions. Leaders should complement buyer review insights with other inputs such as testimonials, references, case studies, and other secondary research.

4.      Not including enough stakeholders. Alignment and clarity across the organization are the best way to ensure that these long-term investments provide maximum business value. Thus, a broad range of input is needed from across the enterprise to determine the best fit. Many organizations narrow their decision-making powers to just a few lines of business, neglecting the fact that these tools will touch the entire organization. IT stakeholders, business stakeholders, users, and executive sponsors should all be included in the decision-making process. This guarantees that the organization is broadly aligned to its objectives and needs, the implementation plans, and how this will affect the organization at large.

Creating a small, focused team that represents all the business units that will use the software saves enterprises the stress of dealing with dissatisfied users, non-adoption, and the use of shadow IT. According to Info-Tech Research Group, the use of shadow IT incurs numerous security, compliance, and operational costs for a business. When IT is not involved in the selection process, there is a higher risk for application performance issues, user experience problems, and overlooking key compliance requirements. Involving IT early in the evaluation and selection process will ensure that the new software will operate effectively within the organization’s current and future technology environment. Organizations can lessen shadow IT by providing technology selection guiding principles, regular internal surveys, and other opportunities to dialogue about evolving priorities with business leaders.

There are several considerations that must be considered when choosing the right SaaS solution for a business. Cost and the features of the technology are important but securing buy-in from all affected parties, doing the right kind of research, and keeping business goals in mind are the keys to ensuring success with any SaaS solution.

##

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

christina-kearney 

Christina Kearny is the CMO at SoftwareReviews (a division of analyst firm, Info-Tech Research Group). She has extensive experience increasing SaaS and Services company revenue and profitability through cross-functional vision and leadership, with relentless focus on employee growth, and customer outcomes.