Opens in a new tab
vmblog logo 2024 wht (updated)

The Essential Checklist for Choosing a vSAN Alternative

Share: 

David Marshall | Published: February 18, 2025

As organizations evaluate alternatives to their current vSAN
solutions or undergo a storage refresh and want to consider a vSAN, they must
look beyond basic storage functionality and consider how architectural choices
impact performance, scalability, and resilience. The right vSAN alternative
should enhance efficiency, reduce costs, and provide long-term flexibility. Use
this checklist to ensure your next storage solution meets your organization’s
needs.

? Performance and Efficiency

  • Integrated
    vs. Separate Storage

    Most vSAN solutions operate as separate virtual machines (VMs) under the
    control of the hypervisor and are treated no differently than application
    VMs. This introduces latency and increases resource overhead. Look for a
    solution where storage is integrated into the hypervisor for optimal
    performance.
  • Optimized
    Storage Utilization

    A well-designed vSAN alternative should maximize storage efficiency by
    reducing write amplification and ensuring low-latency access to data, even
    under heavy workloads.
  • Network
    Efficiency

    The ideal solution should fully utilize available network bandwidth
    without requiring specialized networking hardware to achieve high
    performance.

? Scalability and Flexibility

  • Seamless
    Hardware Compatibility

    Some vSAN solutions require specific, pre-approved hardware, limiting
    future scalability. Choose a solution that supports legacy and modern
    hardware to extend your investment.
  • Flexible
    Storage Architectures

    The ability to mix different types of storage (NVMe, SSD, HDD) within the
    same environment provides greater flexibility and cost efficiency.
  • Multi-Tier
    Storage Support

    Look for solutions that allow workloads to be dynamically moved between
    performance and capacity storage tiers to balance cost and performance as
    demands change.

? Data Protection and Recovery

  • Macro
    Recovery Capabilities

    A true vSAN alternative should offer macro recovery, enabling entire
    environments-such as business units, departments, or entire data center
    instances-to be restored instantly from a single snapshot, minimizing
    downtime.
  • Granular
    Recovery Options

    In addition to macro recovery, ensure the solution allows for individual
    VM or file-level recovery without requiring lengthy restore operations.
  • Efficient
    Snapshot Management

    Solutions that limit the number of snapshots or experience performance
    degradation as snapshots accumulate can restrict recovery flexibility.
    Look for platforms that support frequent snapshots with no impact on
    performance.
  • Resilient
    Data Protection

    Ensure that the alternative uses a distributed replication model for data
    protection instead of relying on erasure coding, which can degrade
    performance and significantly increase rebuild times.

? Cost Considerations

  • No
    Hardware Lock-In

    Some vendors require dedicated “ready nodes” that force customers into
    costly hardware refresh cycles. Choose a solution that allows you to use
    existing hardware and scale on your terms.
  • Efficient
    Resource Utilization

    The ideal vSAN alternative should reduce CPU and RAM overhead, freeing
    resources for application workloads instead of consuming them for storage
    operations.
  • Built-In
    Storage Optimization

    Features like global deduplication, compression, and intelligent data
    placement should be integrated at the core rather than bolted on as
    afterthoughts, ensuring cost-effective storage management.

The VergeIO Advantage

VergeOS is built to address these key considerations,
offering integrated storage, macro recovery, high performance, and flexible
hardware support-all without the inefficiencies of traditional vSAN
architectures. To see why macro recovery is a critical feature in a vSAN
alternative and how it can significantly reduce downtime, check out this
in-depth blog: Understanding
vSAN Snapshots
.